Yankees vs. Blue Jays Dunkel MLB Picks, Predictions and Prop Bets - May 19

The New York Yankees host the Toronto Blue Jays at 7:05 p.m. ET on Tuesday. Will Warren (5-1, 3.42 ERA) will start for the Yankees, who are 29-19 this season and second in the AL East. Dylan Cease (3-1, 2.41 ERA) is the expected starter for the Blue Jays, who are 21-26 and third in the AL East.

The Blue Jays (+115) are on the road versus the favored Yankees (-137). The over/under for the Yankees-Blue Jays game is 8.5.

Yankees vs. Blue Jays Odds, Game Time

• Game day: Tuesday, May 19, 2026
• Game time: 7:05 p.m. ET
• Location: The Bronx, New York
• Stadium: Yankee Stadium
• Favorite: Yankees (-137)
• Underdog: Blue Jays (+115)
• Over/under: 8.5

How to Watch Yankees vs. Blue Jays

• TV Channel: TBS, YES and SN1
• Live Stream: Fubo (Watch for free)

Bet now on FanDuel Sportsbook!

Yankees vs. Blue Jays: Betting the Moneyline

• The Yankees have put together a 27-17 record in games they were listed as the moneyline favorite (winning 61.4% of those games).
• Toronto has come away with five wins in the 18 contests it has been listed as the underdogs in this season.
• New York is 20-10 this season when entering a game favored by -137 or more on the moneyline.
• The Blue Jays have a mark of 1-6 in contests where oddsmakers favor them by +115 or worse on the moneyline.
• The Yankees have a 57.8% chance to win this matchup based on the moneyline's implied probability.
• The Blue Jays have an implied victory probability of 46.5% according to the moneyline set by sportsbooks for this matchup.

Yankees vs. Blue Jays: Betting the Spread & Total

• The Yankees have combined with opponents to hit the over on the total 21 times this season for a 21-24-3 record against the over/under.
• Toronto and its opponents have hit the over in 22 of its 47 games with a total this season.
• The Yankees have put together a 25-23-0 record against the spread this season (covering 52.1% of the time).
• The Blue Jays have posted a record of 21-26-0 against the spread this season.