Athletics vs. Cardinals Dunkel MLB Picks, Predictions and Prop Bets - May 12

Two of MLB's best power hitters face off when the Athletics and St. Louis Cardinals play at Sutter Health Park, at 9:40 p.m. ET on Tuesday. Shea Langeliers has 11 homers (eighth in league) for the Athletics, and Jordan Walker ranks eighth with 11 long balls for the Cardinals. Jeffrey Springs (3-2, 3.89 ERA) will start for the Athletics, who are 21-19 this season and first in the AL West. Andre Pallante (3-3, 4.34 ERA) is expected to start for the Cardinals, who are 23-17 and third in the NL Central.

The Athletics (-154) are moneyline favorites at home over the Cardinals (+128). The game's over/under is 10.

Athletics vs. Cardinals Odds, Game Time

• Game day: Tuesday, May 12, 2026
• Game time: 9:40 p.m. ET
• Location: West Sacramento, California
• Stadium: Sutter Health Park
• Favorite: Athletics (-154)
• Underdog: Cardinals (+128)
• Over/under: 10

How to Watch Athletics vs. Cardinals

• TV Channel: NBCS-CA and CARD
• Live Stream: Fubo (Watch for free)

Bet now on FanDuel Sportsbook!

Athletics vs. Cardinals: Betting the Moneyline

• The Athletics have won 50% of the games this season when they were favored on the moneyline (4-4).
• The Cardinals have been underdogs in 36 games this season and have come away with the win 21 times (58.3%) in those contests.
• This season, the Athletics have won one of their three games when favored by at least -154 on the moneyline.
• This year, the Cardinals have won five of seven games when listed as at least +128 or better on the moneyline.
• Based on this game's moneyline, the Athletics' implied win probability is 60.6%.
• The Cardinals have an implied victory probability of 43.9% according to the moneyline set by oddsmakers for this matchup.

Athletics vs. Cardinals: Betting the Spread & Total

• The Athletics have combined with their opponents to hit the over on the total 19 times this season for a 19-20-1 record against the over/under.
• The Cardinals and their opponents have hit the over in 17 of their 40 games with a total this season.
• The Athletics have a 24-16-0 record ATS this season (covering 60% of the time).
• In 40 games with a line this season, the Cardinals have a mark of 25-15-0 against the spread.